Introduction
In modern building design, fire curtains and fire curtain standards play a pivotal role in life safety and property protection. They allow architects and engineers to create open, welcoming spaces while still ensuring robust fire compartmentation when necessary. Yet, with two main standards in circulation—BS 8524 (British Standard) and EN 16034 (European Standard)—it can be confusing to determine which one most effectively meets your fire safety needs.
In this article, we’ll break down these two standards, highlight their key differences, and explain why BS 8524 is often considered the “gold standard” in the UK for active fire curtain assemblies. We’ll also incorporate insights from industry documents such as Coopers Fire’s white paper, “Setting the standard – why British Standard BS 8524 is the definitive guide for fire curtains,” and our own experiences at Apex Engineering in the South African context.
Why Fire Curtain Standards Matter
Fire curtains aren’t just another building component; they are life-saving devices that deploy when a fire alarm is triggered. Their primary role is to limit the spread of smoke and flames, preserving safe evacuation routes and preventing extensive property damage.
Key aspects that make BS 8524-1 superior include:
- Reliability & Testing: Proper standards (e.g., BS 8524) include rigorous cycling tests, impact tests, and temperature checks to confirm the curtain and its components function correctly, even after extended periods of routine usage.
- Regulatory Compliance: Meeting recognised standards can streamline building approvals and assure all stakeholders (architects, fire engineers, building control officers) that the chosen product meets stringent fire safety requirements.
The Genesis of BS 8524
In the UK, BS 8524 was developed to address the unique challenges posed by active fire curtains, which traditional fire-door tests did not fully capture. Several questions drove the creation of the standard:
- Curtain Impact: What if someone collides with a deployed curtain during an evacuation?
- Motor Reliability: In a real fire scenario, can the curtain re-open to allow individuals (e.g., fire-fighters) to pass underneath, even in extreme temperatures?
- Fabric Durability: After repeated drops (often weekly or monthly tests over several years), will the curtain still maintain its integrity during an actual fire?
BS 8524 answered these by introducing Annexes (A to I) that test:
- Response Time and Durability (Annex D)
- Motor Reliability (Annex E)
- Motor Operation at Elevated Temperatures (Annex G)
- Impact Resistance and long-term performance
Additionally, BS 8524-2 stipulates a code of practice for installation, commissioning, and servicing, ensuring that the entire system remains compliant and reliable over its operational lifetime.
The European Standard: EN 16034
EN 16034 forms part of a broader suite of standards aimed primarily at doors, shutters, windows, and gates. Unlike BS 8524, it was never developed with fire curtains as its sole focus. Key shortcomings include:
- No Clear Guidance on Fire Curtain Operation: Deployment speeds, triggering mechanisms, or warning signals are not fully addressed.
- CE Mark Ambiguity: Achieving CE marking for a “fabric curtain” often requires meeting EN 13241 (applicable to non-fire doors/shutters) or EN 14351-1 (applicable to doors and windows). Fire curtains simply don’t fit neatly into those definitions.
- Limited End-to-End Testing: EN 16034 does not address critical reliability tests—such as elevated-temperature motor operation—that BS 8524 mandates.
Because of these gaps, UK test houses (and the Association for Specialist Fire Protection) advocate that fire curtains should be tested and certified to BS 8524 to meet the necessary performance benchmarks.
Key Differences at a Glance
| Criteria | BS 8524 | EN 16034 |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Solely on fire curtains | Generally for doors, windows, shutters |
| Motor Reliability Testing | Compulsory at elevated temperatures (Annex G) | Not specifically addressed |
| Impact Resistance | Tested (Annex D) | Not covered |
| Installation & Maintenance | Clear guidelines in BS 8524-2, including third-party audits | Minimal or no specific guidance for fire curtains |
| Lifecycle Testing | 500+ cycles prior to furnace testing (Annex D), ensuring fabric durability | No equivalent lifecycle requirement |
| CE Mark Feasibility | Not required for purely UK compliance, stands as a best-practice certification | May be CE marked but often lacks fire curtain–specific testing |
Why BS 8524 Is the “Gold Standard” in the UK
Holistic Testing Approach
From thermal stress to physical impact, BS 8524’s annexes subject a fire curtain to multiple real-world scenarios. These tests confirm that the curtain’s fabric, motors, power supply, and controls continue to function seamlessly, even after years of routine drop-testing.
Comprehensive Installation & Maintenance Protocols
Fire curtains are not “fit-and-forget” systems. Installation quality, coupled with regular servicing, directly impacts reliability. BS 8524-2 details documented procedures for the entire product lifecycle, from the design phase to annual inspections. This includes:
- Confirming there are no structural or decorative elements hindering deployment
- Ensuring motors, control panels, and battery backups work as intended
- Performing regular “drop tests” to verify speed, alignment, and fail-safe operation
Third-Party Audits & Traceability
Manufacturers typically undergo periodic third-party audits (e.g., by UKAS-approved bodies) under BS 8524. This ensures consistent production quality and confirms that each installed system aligns with the original tested design.
Real-World Implications for Building Safety
Fire curtains are lifesaving devices, and the distinction between a thoroughly tested product and one minimally tested can be crucial in an emergency. Opting for a BS 8524–certified product enables:
- Reduced Liability: Clear evidence of due diligence in product choice.
- Simplified Approvals: Building control officers often require or prefer BS 8524 compliance.
- Peace of Mind: Assurance that your fire curtains are tested under realistic conditions.
How Apex Engineering Can Help
At Apex Engineering, we fully appreciate the technical and regulatory complexities tied to active fire curtain assemblies. Our offerings include:
- BS 8524–Compliant Fire Curtains that excel in durability, reliability, and motor performance testing.
- Professional Installation & Maintenance in line with BS 8524-2.
- Advisory Services to guide you through SANS 10400-T, BS 8524, EN 16034, or other local requirements.
- Ongoing Research & Development ensuring our solutions remain on the cutting edge of fire safety technology.
Whether your project is commercial, industrial, or specialised, our experts can tailor a smoke ventilation and fire barrier solution that prioritises both occupant safety and compliance with all relevant regulations.
Conclusion and Next Steps
Choosing the right fire curtain standard can be daunting, but BS 8524 stands out due to its rigorous testing, installation guidelines, and long-term maintenance protocols. By opting for a BS 8524–certified system, you aren’t just fulfilling regulations—you’re actively ensuring your building’s fire protection strategy remains dependable over the long haul.
Ready to elevate your fire safety measures?
Visit our website to learn more about our fire curtains and other smoke ventilation solutions
Frequently Asked Questions
For more information on smoke control systems, contact Apex Engineering.
